In a hilariously improvised segment on ‘Late Night,’ Jimmy Fallon and former ‘Saturday Night Live’ co-star Horatio Sanz reunited for an improvised sketch called ‘A Drawer Full of Memories.’

In the TV drama spoof, Fallon and Sanz don absurd black wigs, drawing giggles from the audience. But the real laughs begin when they can’t agree upon the particulars of the narrative (their father held jobs as both a “jack-o-lantern” and “bone inspector”) and, like they used to do in their ‘SNL’ days, struggle to keep straight faces.

Watch the skit below:

[Late Night With Jimmy Fallon]